top of page
Search

ELC Childcare vs. Private Daycare in Florida: What Parents Need to Know

Navigating Your Childcare Options: Why This Comparison Matters 

Choosing the right early learning environment for your child is one of the most significant decisions a parent makes. It impacts everything from your family’s budget to your child’s educational trajectory. Across the Sunshine State, and particularly in high-demand areas like Broward County, parents often face a crucial choice: should they opt for subsidized care through the Early Learning Coalition (ELC) or enroll their child in a fully Private Daycare? 


It’s easy to feel overwhelmed by acronyms, waitlists, and conflicting advice. This comprehensive guide cuts through the confusion, providing a clear, authoritative comparison of ELC Childcare vs. Private Daycare. By the end of this guide, you’ll know which option best fits your child’s needs and your family’s budget, helping you secure the best foundation for your child's future. 


Table of Contents 


Teacher reading to children in a daycare setting — illustrating ELC Childcare vs. Private Daycare in Florida.

 

Key Takeaways: ELC Childcare vs. Private Daycare 

  1. Cost vs. Eligibility: ELC (Early Learning Coalition) Childcare primarily functions as a subsidy program for eligible low-income working families through School Readiness funding, making the costs significantly lower (often a co-pay). Private Daycare requires parents to pay full, unsubsidized tuition but has open enrollment regardless of income or work status. 

  2. The Stark Financial Difference: For eligible low-income families, the financial impact is profound: ELC subsidies typically reduce the out-of-pocket cost from an average full private tuition of $1,250/month to an income-tested co-payment often ranging from $40 to $150 per month. 

  3. Curriculum Focus: ELC providers are heavily focused on meeting Florida's state educational standards, including the mandatory Voluntary Prekindergarten (VPK) program for 4-year-olds. Private Daycares, while also meeting state minimums, offer a wider variety of specialized educational philosophies (e.g., Montessori, STEM, Reggio Emilia). 

  4. Flexibility and Hours: Private Daycares typically offer far greater flexibility in scheduling, including extended operating hours, full-time, part-time, and sometimes drop-in options. ELC-funded care often operates under more standardized hours aligned with school calendars and work/school requirements. 

  5. Local Action is Crucial: Regardless of the model, quality standards (ratios, staffing, and licensing) are governed by the state. Parents in the Pembroke Pines area must contact ELC Broward for any subsidy applications or VPK vouchers, and should tour both ELC-participating and fully private centers to compare quality and culture firsthand. 

 

Understanding the Two Models: Definitions and Oversight 

The fundamental difference between these two options lies in funding, mission, and accessibility. 

What is ELC Childcare in Florida? 

ELC Childcare refers to services administered and subsidized by Florida's network of Early Learning Coalitions (ELCs), such as ELC Florida in Broward County. The core goal of the ELC is to improve the quality of early education and ensure it is accessible to all families, regardless of income. 

  • Role of the Early Learning Coalition (ELC): The ELC manages state and federal funds to provide financial assistance, primarily through the School Readiness (SR) program and Voluntary Prekindergarten (VPK). 

  • Overview of Subsidies and Funding Sources: The ELC does not operate the childcare centers directly; instead, it provides scholarships (subsidies) to eligible low- and moderate-income families. These funds are then used at participating, licensed private or public childcare providers. 


What is a Private Daycare Center? 

A Private Daycare center is a facility that is privately owned, operated, and funded almost entirely through parent tuition. While they must meet state licensing standards set by the Florida Department of Children and Families (DCF), they have greater autonomy in their business model, scheduling, and curriculum choices. 

  • Defining Privately Owned and Operated Facilities: These centers range from large corporate chains to smaller, independent, or "boutique" operations like a Pembroke Pines early development center. 

  • The Range of Educational Philosophies: Private facilities often differentiate themselves by offering specialized curricula, such as Montessori, Reggio Emilia, high-level STEM programs, or dedicated foreign language immersion, providing parents with a wide array of choices. 

 

Side-by-Side Comparison Table: ELC Childcare vs. Private Daycare 

To quickly understand the core differences, here is a high-level comparison of the two models: 

Feature 

ELC Childcare (School Readiness) 

Private Daycare (Tuition-Based) 

Funding Source 

Government Subsidies (State/Federal) 

Parent Tuition & Private Funds 

Cost to Parent 

Based on Sliding Scale (Income-Tested Co-payment) 

Full Market Rate Tuition 

Eligibility 

Income and Work/Education Requirements Must Be Met 

Open to All, No Financial Criteria 

Curriculum Focus 

State-mandated School Readiness Standards & VPK 

Varied (e.g., Montessori, STEM, Play-Based) 

Schedule Flexibility 

Generally standard hours; coverage limited by need/subsidy 

Highly flexible (e.g., Extended hours, drop-in options) 

Enrollment Speed 

Often involves a waitlist after eligibility is confirmed 

Typically faster, dependent on enrollment capacity 


Key Difference 1: Cost, Eligibility, and Financial Aid 

The most significant divergence between the two models centers on accessibility and financial structure. 

Regulatory and Financial Transparency Note: All childcare centers in Florida, both ELC-affiliated and private, are licensed and regulated by the Florida Department of Children and Families (DCF). The specific cost ranges cited for private care are based on average market data for the South Florida metropolitan statistical area in the current fiscal year. 


Eligibility and Enrollment: Who Qualifies for ELC? 

Access to ELC's School Readiness (SR) program is strictly income-based and tied to family activity. To qualify for ELC funding in Broward County and across Florida, families typically must: 

  • Have a gross income at or below 150 percent of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) at the time of initial enrollment. 

  • Parents must be working or participating in approved educational activities (such as attending college or vocational school) for at least 20 hours per week (or a combined 40 hours for two-parent households). 

  • The child must be under the age of 13. 


In contrast, enrolling in a private daycare, such as a local Pembroke Pines Daycare, is open to all families, regardless of income or employment status, provided the facility has an opening, and you can pay the full tuition. 


Comparing ELC Subsidies vs. Private Out-of-Pocket Tuition 

Private Daycare Tuition: In major metropolitan areas like South Florida, infant care can range from $900 to over $1,500 per month. This is a full, out-of-pocket expense for the parent. 


ELC Subsidies: The ELC system provides a School Readiness (SR) voucher that covers the majority of the tuition cost. The family is then responsible for a calculated co-payment based on a sliding fee scale related to their income and family size. This co-payment is often drastically lower than private tuition, making quality care affordable. 


The Real Cost of Childcare: Mandatory Fees and Incidentals 

While ELC covers the core tuition, both options may charge additional fees: 

  • ELC Centers: The provider may charge a "tuition difference" or "co-pay difference" if their full-time rate exceeds the standard maximum reimbursement rate set by the ELC. They also often charge for activity fees, field trips, or supplies not covered by the subsidy. 

  • Private Daycare: Expect annual registration fees, materials fees, and potentially higher charges for specialized programs or meals. 


Key Difference 2: Curriculum, VPK, and Educational Focus 

While all licensed facilities must meet minimum safety standards, the curriculum approach varies significantly. 


VPK and Readiness Programs: The ELC Focus 

ELC-affiliated centers prioritize the state-mandated School Readiness goals and often participate in the Voluntary Prekindergarten (VPK) program for 4-year-olds. 

  • Goal: To ensure children are ready for kindergarten entry by focusing on literacy, numeracy, and social-emotional development. 

  • VPK: This is a free program (regardless of income) offered by both ELC-affiliated and non-affiliated centers, providing 540 instructional hours annually to all Florida 4-year-olds. ELC providers often integrate VPK into their School Readiness model. 



Varied Approaches in Private Daycare (STEM, Reggio, etc.) 

Private facilities offer competitive differentiation through their educational philosophy. 

  • Specialized Curricula: A Pembroke Pines Daycare might implement the renowned Montessori method, focusing on self-directed activity, or a cutting-edge STEM curriculum, designed to foster early problem-solving skills. 

  • Depth of Program: These programs often offer greater depth or concentration in specific areas (like arts or language) that go beyond the state's minimum standards. 


Assessment and Developmental Monitoring 

Both ELC and private providers conduct developmental screenings. However, ELC providers are required to adhere to specific state assessment protocols (like the Florida Early Learning and Developmental Standards) used by the Coalition to track program effectiveness and child progress for accountability. 


Key Difference 3: Staffing, Ratios, and Quality Standards 

While the state of Florida sets minimum staff-to-child ratios, the quality of care often depends on whether a provider chooses to exceed these benchmarks. 


Teacher Qualifications and Training Requirements (State Standards vs. Private) 

  • State Minimums (ELC/Private): All teachers must meet DCF licensing requirements, including completing the 40-hour introductory child care training. 

  • Enhanced Standards (Private): High-quality private centers often require staff to hold credentials like the Child Development Associate (CDA) or a bachelor's degree in Early Childhood Education (ECE), especially for lead teacher roles. This emphasis on professional development contributes to the facility’s overall EEAT score. 


Staff-to-Child Ratios and Group Sizes (In-Depth Analysis) 

Florida law sets the maximum ratio. However, national early childhood experts, such as the NAEYC, recommend lower ratios than the state mandates for optimal development. 

Child Age 

Florida State Minimum Ratio 

Recommended "Gold Standard" Ratio 

Infants (0–12 mos) 

1:4 

1:3 

1 Year Olds 

1:6 

1:4 

2-Year-Olds 

1:11 

1:5 or 1:6 

  • ELC Centers: Must meet the Florida State Minimum Ratio to retain their license and ELC contract. 

  • Private Daycare: Premium private centers often invest in lower ratios (closer to the "Gold Standard") to market their quality, resulting in more individualized attention per child. 


Licensing and Accreditation (FL DOE vs. NAEYC) 

Both ELC-affiliated and private centers must be licensed by the State of Florida. However, voluntary accreditations signal higher quality: 


Key Difference 4: Scheduling, Flexibility, and Operating Hours 

For working parents, scheduling often dictates the final choice. 


ELC’s Standardized Hours and School Calendar Alignments 

ELC subsidies are granted based on demonstrated need (parent work/school hours) and are typically fixed. 

  • Hours: Subsidized care may not cover a full 10- or 12-hour day, requiring parents to pay the difference if extended care is needed. 

  • Breaks: ELC funding often aligns with the public school calendar, meaning coverage during summer breaks, holidays, or school closings may be limited or require additional planning/payment. 


The Extended Flexibility of Private Daycare (Full-Time, Part-Time, Drop-In) 

Private centers thrive on flexibility to meet diverse family schedules. 

  • Custom Options: Most private Pembroke Pines Daycare facilities offer late operating hours (e.g., 6:30 AM to 6:30 PM), part-time enrollment, flexible four-day schedules, and even emergency drop-in slots, which are rarely available in the subsidized system. 


Local Focus: Childcare Programs in Pembroke Pines & Broward County 

For families in South Florida, the choice is highly localized. The Early Learning Coalition of Broward County (ELC Broward) is the key resource for administering the School Readiness and VPK programs in this region. If you are seeking subsidized care, ELC Broward is your first point of contact. Many excellent providers, including top-rated private centers, partner with ELC Broward to accept subsidies. 


When searching for a high-quality private program, look for a reputable Pembroke Pines Early Development Center that advertises its specific curriculum, low ratios, and NAEYC accreditation. 

  • Broward County Childcare Licensing: Furthermore, all facilities in this area are subject to additional local oversight and licensing requirements administered through the Broward County Office of Child Care and Licensing. 

 

The Parents' Decision Guide: Pros, Cons, and Next Steps 

Deciding between ELC Childcare vs. Private Daycare requires weighing the financial benefits against the scheduling and specialized program differences. 


Pros and Cons of ELC Childcare 

Pros 

Cons 

Affordability: Drastically reduces costs via subsidies. 

Eligibility Required: Strict income and work/school criteria. 

Quality Control: Providers must meet minimum ELC performance standards. 

Waitlists: Enrollment is often slow due to high demand. 

Focus: Strong focus on kindergarten readiness standards. 

Lower Flexibility: Hours and enrollment are less flexible. 

 

Pros and Cons of Private Daycare 

Pros 

Cons 

Flexibility: Extended hours and flexible scheduling. 

High Cost: Requires full tuition payment (high out-of-pocket). 

Program Variety: Access to specialized curricula (Montessori, STEM). 

Quality Varies: Must carefully vet licenses and accreditations. 

Accessibility: No income test; faster enrollment (if space is open). 

No Subsidies: Only VPK is free; no aid for younger children. 

 

Final Checklist: Which Option Best Fits Your Family? 

  • Choose ELC Childcare If: Your family qualifies based on income, you need significant cost savings, and your work/school schedule is standard and consistent. 

  • Choose Private Daycare If: Your income exceeds ELC limits, you require extended/flexible hours (early drop-off/late pickup), or you prioritize a specific educational philosophy (like STEM or language immersion). 


Conclusion 

The complexity of the choice between ELC Childcare vs. Private Daycare shouldn't keep you from finding the ideal setting for your child. Whether you prioritize financial assistance through ELC Florida or specialized programs at a Pembroke Pines Daycare, the ultimate decision should be rooted in careful research and a personal visit. 


We strongly encourage parents to tour both types of centers before deciding. Seeing the environment, observing the teacher-child interactions, and discussing the curriculum in person provides the best insight. 


Ready to explore the best early development center for your child? Contact Nowtech Academy to learn more about our accredited programs or schedule a visit to see our facilities today. 

 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Florida Childcare 

Q1: What is ELC Childcare in Florida? 

A: ELC Childcare refers to the subsidized financial assistance program (School Readiness) managed by the Early Learning Coalitions in Florida. It provides financial aid to help low- and moderate-income families pay for child care at participating private and public providers, ensuring their children receive a strong educational foundation before kindergarten. 


Q2: Is private daycare better than ELC childcare? 

A: Neither is inherently "better." ELC-affiliated care is generally more affordable and focuses heavily on state-mandated readiness standards. Private daycare offers greater flexibility, lower child-to-staff ratios (at premium centers), and specialized educational curricula, but at a much higher cost. The best choice depends on your family's financial needs and educational priorities. 


Q3: How do I apply for ELC funding in Broward County? 

A: To apply for ELC funding (School Readiness) in Broward County, you must contact the Early Learning Coalition of Broward County (ELC Broward) and complete an application via their official Family Portal. You will need to provide documentation proving your income, employment/school hours, and residency. 


Q4: Does ELC cover full-time daycare? 

A: Yes, ELC School Readiness can cover full-time care, but the subsidy amount is based on the family’s documented need (work/school hours). Families must pay a mandatory co-payment, and they may also be responsible for any tuition difference charged by the provider that exceeds the ELC's maximum reimbursement rate. 


Q5: What’s the average cost of private daycare in Pembroke Pines? 

A: The cost of private daycare in the Pembroke Pines area, which is part of the high-cost South Florida market, is generally higher than the state average. For full-time infant care, parents can expect to pay anywhere from $1,050 to $1,500+ per month, depending on the provider's specific program, ratios, and offerings. 



bottom of page